Buffalo Springfield - "Buffalo Springfield" Vinyl, Mono, Album, 1967 (ATCO Records)

Buffalo Springfield had so many pluses that it eventually erased what's good about the band and left the drab, which turned into disappointment. The solid songs mostly by Steve Stills and Neil Young, as well as Richie Furay's contributions,  is almost too good. Their first album "Buffalo Springfield" is my favorite among the three releases. For one, here they were focused and produced by one team: Brian Stone and Charles Greene. Those two worked with Sonny & Cher, as well as other acts on the label ATCO. I also believed they were the managers of Springfield as well. Still, the consistency is important, but on the negative side, their production is wimpy. I suspect Buffalo Springfield on the stage were guitar lunatics, and due to the egos of Stills and Young, probably a battle of the bands, even though they were in the same group. That's the problem with their next two releases where the sense of a band falling apart, and becoming various solo recordings, made the music limp. There are highlights throughout their existence, but I have always had the feeling that they could have been better in the recording studio. It's a shame that Jack Nitzsche didn't produce or arrange all the songs. He would have been a perfect producer for this band.

Having Richie Furay singing most of the material was a good idea at the time. His voice is heavenly clear, and although Stills and Young do have a 'sound' in their distinctive vocals, they come nowhere to the technical excellence of Furay's approach to the vocal. Again, I find the recording of this album very thin, and the production doesn't serve the masterful playing of the band. I feel that they are too contained in the format that's the studio.  For 50 something years, this album has been in and out of my record collection. I finally found a vintage mono edition, and still, not satisfied with the sound. Almost there, and you can even taste it, but still a distance. 

Buffalo Springfield - "Buffalo Springfield" 2 x Vinyl, LP, Compilation, 1973 (Atco)

The one word that comes to my mind when I hear the name "Buffalo Springfield" is frustration.  This is a band that should have gone to a higher level of greatness, but I suspect ego got in the way of the direction to go upwards.   Still, they left three albums that are very good, but this compilation of those three records are the best introduction to the Buffalo Springfield world.  

The beauty of the band was the perfect set-up or relationship between the dueling lead guitars of Steve Stills and Neil Young, and Richie Furay's superb vocals and rhythm guitar.  With the soul/Stax drumming of Dewey Martin, and who I suspect is the real star of the group, Bruce Palmer on bass.  Part of the sadness I feel is that this is a band that lost an opportunity of making a permanent presence on the stage.  What I have seen from one clip of them playing live on TV, is incredible.   The tension between the players reminds me of the original set-up of Television with Tom Verlaine and Richard Lloyd.  All play guitars, but at times it seems that they were having a communication between themselves, and us listeners were allowed to listen in.    The fact that Stills/Young tried to do something with the Springfield, and then with the terrible CSNY, and then the Stills/Young album/tour, well, I guess they tried.  The fact is these were two different type of musicians/songwriters, and I think they genuinely needed each other, to make their work more consistent and robust.   I'm not a fan of solo Neil or solo Stills, but when they combine their talents in Buffalo Springfield, it was magnificent.  The sad thing is that there is no film footage of them on stage, and worse, no live recordings.   Just hearing the extended version of Stills' "Bluebird" is fantastic.   One of the great guitar rave-ups in recorded history!

The band playing together was equal, but again, I think their recordings are a hit and miss.  The first album, produced by Greene and Stone, miss the intensity of the songs and their performance.  Still, "Mr. Soul" and "For What's it's Worth" are amazing records.  The other secret weapon is Richie Furay, who is an incredible singer.   Both in harmony and lead vocals.   And there should have been a full-use of the genius Jack Nitzsche, for instance, he should have arranged the entire works of Buffalo Springfield, not only on the Neil stuff but all the other material as well.   After the first album, it became a situation where each band member produced his composition and so forth.   So in a sense, you have a series of solo recordings within the Buffalo Springfield landscape.   

Buffalo Springfield was a super band, but due to its character, it burned itself out before doing something incredible.   This double compilation album is pretty great.  Still, I feel that there was more work to be done.  The story is not over yet.